Why Don’t Catholics Buy More Catholic Books?
That’s the question Lauren Winner asks in a recent article in Publishers Weekly. More precisely, she asks why Catholics buy so many fewer books than Protestant Evangelicals. The people she talked to – Catholic editors and marketers for the most part – have a litany of answers. Protestants are people of the Word; Catholics are people of sacrament and liturgy. Pastors recommend books from the pulpit; priests don’t. Entrepreneurial Evangelicals market books aggressively and distribute them widely; Catholic publishers are content to be diffident and small. Paracelete’s Lil Copan thinks that Catholics buy plenty of books. They just don’t buy as many religious ones:
“Though CBA readers have had a long tradition of buying mainly in CBA stores, the liturgical reader has always been just as likely to walk into an independent or a Barnes & Noble. Once they are in that bookstore, liturgical Christians may not be focused only on the religion/spirituality aisles. I have not one single fact, percentage point or overheard comment to back this up, but have observed that liturgical readers will be more likely to pick up a literary novel, a book of historical note or a book on faith formation, with no sense of pressure that they need to read something religious or even something that is considered ‘church-approved’ and orthodox.”
Copan’s remarks point toward the huge difference between Evangelical and Catholic religious culture. Protestant Evangelicals turn to Christian books for all life’s needs, from diet counseling to marriage enrichment to pulp novel entertainment. Most Catholics wouldn’t dream of buying a Catholic book for any of these things.