How Priests Are Made
I’ve been around priests all my life, and I’ve gotten to know a few, including my uncle and several colleagues I’ve worked closely with. But priests remain mysterious. Their vocation isn’t mine. Neither is their life, which seems to me extraordinarily demanding. But I’ve gotten to know priests better through an excellent new book, The Collar: A Year of Striving and Faith Inside a Catholic Seminary by Jonathan Englert, a journalist and convert who followed five men through a year of seminary and weaved their stories into a dramatic narrative as gripping as a good novel. The men attended Sacred Heart Semininary in Wisconsin, which specializes in training older, second-career men. Englert’s five seminarians are unusual would-be priests: three had been married (two divorced, one a widower), one had been a salesman and a Marine, another was a blind musician. We get to know them well as they learn what the priestly vocation really involves and decide if they are truly suited for it. After the year, three of them continue at Sacred Heart; two do not.
It’s a most challenging job. Toward the end, Englert observes: “there were so many things that these new priests would have to consider: greater and lesser goods; the pastoral reality of finding one’s community where it was, not where one would like it to be; the seesaw between those tense companions mercy and justice; the broken world itself, and the hard, patient, and tender work of being a man of God in such a world.”